Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image

| September 19, 2018

Scroll to top

Top

Promises Archives -

Study Shows Many ICO Protocols Fail to Match White Paper Promises

July 19, 2018 |

Study Shows Many ICO Protocols Fail to Match White Paper Promises

On July 19, a group of interdisciplinary researchers from the University of Pennsylvania, with guidance from the esteemed Penn Law professor David Hoffman, published an in-depth study of initial coin offerings (ICOs) that promise innovative concepts like autonomous governance and operate by the belief that ‘code is law’. However, most of the ICOs the group researched failed to match the original contractual promises and the so-called ‘trustless trust’ offered by these projects had very little merit.

Also read: Japan Tax Agency Says Individuals Earning $ 1,800+ in Crypto a Year Will Declare Tax

University of Pennsylvania Study Looks Into Whether ICO White Paper Promises Match the Project’s Codebase  

Study Shows Many ICO Protocols Fail to Match White Paper PromisesThis week, researchers from the University of Pennsylvania and Penn Law professor David Hoffman have published an interesting working paper on ICOs called “Coin Operated Capitalism.” The paper was authored by university members Shaanan Cohney (computer science PHd),  David Wishnick (a fellow at Penn Law’s interdisciplinary Center for Technology), and Jeremy Sklaroff (Penn’s JD/MBA program).    

The study’s authors surveyed and audited the top 50 ICOs that raised the most funds in 2017 and researchers looked at whether or not the ICO promises made by the promoters and white papers actually matched the technology’s codebase. The study finds that there are glaring differences between what the ICOs’ code delivers and what the creators promised to their investors.

“The automated mechanisms found in code—known as ‘smart contracts’—are not the only way entrepreneurs can deliver on their promises,” Wishnick explained.

But, according to proponents, they are what make ICOs innovative.

Study Shows Many ICO Protocols Fail to Match White Paper Promises
Researchers from Penn Law looked at ICOs such as Tezos, Filecoin, EOS, Bancor, Tron, Tenx, Civic, Chainlink, Storj, Power Ledger, and many more.

Only 20% of 50 ICO Codebases Matched the Promoter’s Promises

Out of the 50 ICOs surveyed, using both the white papers (contracts) and the codebases (delivered or non-delivered promises), a great deal of the ICO code and their associated ICO contracts did not match. In fact, only 20 percent of the 50 contracts surveyed matched their promises to code 100 percent of the time. “Nearly 60 percent made a least one governance promise that was missing from the code, and 20 percent had two or more mismatches,” the study’s authors emphasize.

“Surprisingly, in a community known for espousing a techno-libertarian belief in the power of ‘trustless trust’ built with carefully designed code, a significant fraction of issuers retained centralized control through previously undisclosed code permitting modification of the entities’ governing structures,” the working paper explains.

In Contrast to Traditional Law, the Smart Contract Community Is Full of Energy But So-Called Autonomous Protocols Need Vetting and Code Auditing

The paper concludes that the informality of smart-contract production does lead to “risks” but also “creativity”. Smart contract developers are far more creative than a “community of lawyers who tend to recycle language from agreement to agreement without much thought,” the study states. In contrast, the smart contract community has a lot of passion and energy, the researchers explain. But the study shows the manufacturing of smart contracts and blockchain promises must be evaluated and scrutinized closely.   

“Beyond the production of smart contracts and blockchain code, our study also highlights the importance of the ecosystem through which crypto code is vetted, audited, and made legible to the outside world,” the paper concludes.

What do you think about the Penn Law working paper that details most ICO code does not match the promises tied to the project? Let us know what you think in the comment section below. 


Images via Shutterstock, and the University of Pennsylvania


Bitcoin.com there’s a bunch of free helpful services. For instance, have you seen our Tools page? You can even look up the exchange rate for a transaction in the past. Or calculate the value of your current holdings. Or create a paper wallet. And much more.

The post Study Shows Many ICO Protocols Fail to Match White Paper Promises appeared first on Bitcoin News.

Bitcoin News

Elon Musk Promises to Fix Flint Water Contamination

July 12, 2018 |

He sent a sports car to space , but can he fix Flint’s water crisis? Elon Musk says the answer is yes. In response to a request on Twitter Wednesday, the Tesla and SpaceX CEO promised that he would deal with the scandal in the Michigan city, where the water supply…
Newser

Amazon Promises an ‘Epic’ 36 Hours of Shopping

July 3, 2018 |

A “day” is traditionally defined as 24 hours, but in Amazon’s case, it could also mean 36. The latter is what the online giant is allotting for its upcoming Amazon Prime Day on July 16, kicking off the online sales at 3pm that day, per CNNMoney . Billing what’s usually its…
Newser

After Victory, Erdogan Promises to Build a Stronger Country

June 25, 2018 |

President Recep Tayyip Erdogan celebrated his twin victory in presidential and parliamentary elections, heralding a more assertive Turkey rooted in nationalism as much as in conservative Islam.
WSJ.com: What’s News Europe

CNN

Dennis Rodman: Kim is not used to fulfilled promises

June 12, 2018 |

CNN’s Chris Cuomo speaks to former NBA player Dennis Rodman from Singapore as President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong Un meet in a historic summit.
CNN.com – RSS Channel – World

HSBC CEO Promises to Invest $17 Billion in Technology, Asia Growth

June 12, 2018 |

HSBC’s new chief executive said the bank is in growth mode and plans to invest up to $ 17 billion in China and new technologies, but ruled out major acquisitions in the near future.
WSJ.com: What’s News Asia

The Hard Part for Trump: Making North Korea Keep Summit Promises

June 8, 2018 |

President Donald Trump’s effort to wrestle a commitment from North Korean leader Kim Jong Un to yield his nuclear weapons program in exchange for security guarantees is just the start of a complex process.
WSJ.com: What’s News Asia

Delta promises few construction headaches from its $1.9-billion LAX upgrade

June 3, 2018 |

Delta Air Lines launched a massive and complicated move at Los Angeles International Airport last year, an operation that gave the carrier access to seven new gates but required 19 other carriers to relocate.

Now the Atlanta-based airline has begun a $ 1.9-billion construction project to upgrade…


L.A. Times – Business

Belgian Singer Promises ‘Rebirth,’ Dies Next Day

May 8, 2018 |

“I really believed for almost a year that I would never sing again,” Belgian singer Maurane, real name Claudine Luypaerts, said in a Sunday interview, describing a “rebirth,” per the BBC . Over the weekend, the singer participated in a concert in Brussels, which was to mark the start of a…
Newser

Tough Choices Loom for Theresa May to Meet Brexit Promises

May 3, 2018 |

Prime Minister Theresa May has been able to hold a divided nation together by ducking or denying hard choices. But that strategy has run out of road, Simon Nixon writes.
WSJ.com: What’s News Europe